Every December I tell myself I'll make one kind of Christmas cookie. Then I'm standing in my kitchen at 9pm with four kinds of dough and sprinkles in places sprinkles should not be. If you're making a cookie box this year, for neighbors, teachers, a cookie swap, or just your own kitchen counter, these are the 12 easy Christmas cookies I'd put in it.

a note from caitlin
Cookie boxes are my favorite way to say I love you in December. Bake two or three of these, add one no-bake treat, and you’ll have a box that looks like it came from a bakery. Happy baking!
xo, Caitlin
A good cookie box is all about the mix: something chewy, something chocolatey, something with crunch, and one thing that doesn't need the oven at all. Pick four or five from this list and you've got a box people will actually remember.
How to Build a Christmas Cookie Box
- Mix your textures. Pair a soft cookie (like the sprinkle sugar cookies) with a crunchy one (like the kitchen sink cookies) and something fudgy.
- Include one no-bake treat. It saves oven space and adds variety (my Cookie Butter Puppy Chow is a crowd favorite). See the box fillers at the end.
- Bake the sturdy cookies first. Unfrosted cookies hold up best, so make those earliest and save the frosted or marshmallow-topped ones for last.
- Freeze dough ahead. Scoop your dough into balls, freeze them, and bake straight from frozen in December. Check each recipe for timing.
- Pack smart. Let everything cool completely, separate layers with parchment, and put the heaviest cookies on the bottom.
free cookie baking guide!
Get my Ultimate Guide to Cookie Baking, a free printable e-book with my best tips and tricks for perfect cookies every time. Just pop in your name and email!

The one people will ask you about. You make a pan of buttery saltine toffee, chop it up, and fold it into chewy chocolate chip cookie dough, so every bite is salty, sweet, crunchy, and soft at the same time. They look fancy with zero decorating.


The soft, cheerful one in the box, and the cookie the kids go for first. No chilling, no rolling, no cookie cutters. They stay soft for days, so you can bake them ahead.


Every box needs one cookie that's a little unhinged. Pretzels, red and green M&Ms, white chocolate, and sprinkles all in one cookie. They're sturdy too, so they're great for stacking and shipping.


For the chocolate people. Made with melted chocolate for a fudgy, brownie-like middle, then loaded with M&Ms, white chocolate, and sprinkles.


A cup of hot cocoa in cookie form: a rich chocolate cookie with a gooey marshmallow on top. Pack these in a single layer so the marshmallows don't stick to everything.


Soft, chewy, deep cocoa cookies with a peppermint twist. They make your whole box taste like December.


Soft, chewy eggnog cookies with cream cheese frosting. Since they're frosted, keep them in the fridge and add them to the box last.


Soft chocolate cookies with a red and white striped peppermint kiss pressed on top. They're the prettiest cookie in the box with almost no effort.


Chewy peanut butter cookies with red and green M&Ms. Easy, colorful, and always one of the first to disappear.


Chewy, buttery cookies packed with caramelized toffee bits. If your box needs something that isn't chocolate, this is it.


Rich, fudgy cookies with a gooey chocolate center. They look like you spent all day on them. You didn't.

The no-bake one. Creamy, rich, and just sweet enough. Make these when the oven is already full of everything else.

Box Fillers: Bars and No-Bake Treats
These fill the gaps in the tin and make the box look extra full:
- Christmas Sugar Cookie Bars: sugar cookie bars with fluffy vanilla buttercream and sprinkles. No rolling, no chilling.
- Christmas Crack Bars: salty, sweet, crunchy, and gooey, with only 5 ingredients.
- Cookie Butter Puppy Chow: no-bake Chex mix with Biscoff and white chocolate. Ready in 30 minutes.
- Muddy Buddy Truffles: sweet, crunchy, and no-bake.
Christmas Cookie Box FAQs
How far ahead can I make a Christmas cookie box?
Most unfrosted cookies keep for several days in an airtight container, and many cookie doughs freeze well, so you can bake in batches. Bake the sturdy cookies first and add frosted or marshmallow-topped cookies the day you gift. Check each recipe for its own storage tips.
How many kinds of cookies should go in a cookie box?
Four to six kinds is the sweet spot. That's enough variety to feel special without spending every night of December baking.
How do I keep cookies fresh in the box?
Let them cool completely before packing, keep soft and crunchy cookies separated with parchment (soft cookies can make crunchy ones go soft), and close the tin tightly. Keep anything with cream cheese frosting in the fridge until you give it.
Looking for more? Check out all of my holiday recipes. And if you make any of these, tag me on Instagram @caitlins_table. I love seeing your cookie boxes!
more christmas treats you’ll love













No Comments